Antibiotic Disruption and Symbiont-Transfer Evidence for Gut-Microbiota-Mediated Insecticide Resistance in Agricultural and Vector Insects: A Systematic Review and Mechanistic Evidence Map of Detoxification Enzymes, Pesticide Classes, and Host-Fitness Costs

Authors

  • Bashaer yaseen mehdi College of Education for Pure Sciences

Keywords:

gut microbiota, insecticide resistance, symbiont-mediated detoxification, organophosphate, disease vectors, holobiont, risk of bias, evidence synthesis

Abstract

Background. Insecticide resistance threatens crop protection and vector-borne-disease control worldwide. Beyond the insect's own genome, gut-associated microorganisms are increasingly implicated in resistance through direct insecticide degradation, microbial detoxification enzymes, and modulation of host detoxification pathways. However, most reports establish only correlation, and the field has not been synthesised according to the strength of causal evidence.

Objectives. To systematically map the evidence that gut microbiota mediate insecticide resistance in agricultural pests and arthropod disease vectors, to grade that evidence along a predefined causal hierarchy, and to relate it to detoxification enzymes, insecticide classes, and host-fitness costs.

Methods. We searched five multidisciplinary databases and grey-literature sources following PRISMA 2020 and PRISMA-S. Eligible studies covered associational (Category A), perturbation (Category B), and transfer/rescue (Category C) designs. Data were extracted into a structured database; risk of bias was appraised with a domain-based tool adapted for microbiome-manipulation experiments; findings were synthesised narratively (SWiM) and, for a comparable subset, by exploratory random-effects meta-analysis of the log response ratio (lnRR) of survival.

Results. Forty-one primary studies (2012–2025) met the criteria, dominated by Diptera and Hemiptera and skewed toward organophosphates. Category-A associations were abundant, but only a minority reached Category C. The strongest evidence—gene-resolved microbial degradation with a demonstrated host phenotype—was confined to the Riptortus–Burkholderia and Bactrocera–Citrobacter organophosphate systems and to a cockroach–oxadiazine transfer model. The exploratory meta-analysis (12 comparisons) indicated a positive but highly heterogeneous pooled effect (lnRR ≈ 0.55; I² ≈ 84%). Verified microbiota depletion and antibiotic-toxicity controls were frequently absent.

Conclusions. Evidence that microbiota correlate with insecticide resistance is far broader than evidence that microbiota are sufficient to transfer the resistant phenotype. Standardised depletion protocols, reciprocal transfer experiments, functional gene validation, and fitness-cost measurement are the priority gaps. Gut microbiota are promising surveillance and management targets but are not yet a deployable control lever.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-15

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

1.
Bashaer yaseen mehdi. Antibiotic Disruption and Symbiont-Transfer Evidence for Gut-Microbiota-Mediated Insecticide Resistance in Agricultural and Vector Insects: A Systematic Review and Mechanistic Evidence Map of Detoxification Enzymes, Pesticide Classes, and Host-Fitness Costs. Sawa Med. J. [Internet]. 2026 Nov. 15 [cited 2026 Nov. 17];2(4):1104-33. Available from: https://smj.sawauniversity.edu.iq/article/view/916